Showing posts with label week 2. Show all posts
Showing posts with label week 2. Show all posts

Saturday, May 26, 2012

My Birther Opinion


This is just my opinion, in response to the article on, “birther buffoonery”.

In this article you have those with nothing better to do than to set around and contemplate about the nativity of the President: Those same groups of small minded individuals, who most likely, come from an ancestry of bigotry and oppression, who still believe that the color of their skin gives them the right to be held as a majority over those of darker skin.

Let’s face it America, bigotry is still alive and kicking, it just go under fancier terms. There are too many other problems that our nation has to face every day, within and beyond its borders that should be addressed, instead of trying to break down the nativity of an elected leader because one is appalled by the color of the elected skin tone.

Before this article, I had no idea what a birther was or what the whole birtherism movement was in regard to. Now that I do know, I find the entire made-up, so call justification requirements of an individual’s nomination into an electoral presidential office laughable.

Not to step on anyone toes, but in my opinion there will only be two races of natural born Americans: Those that were already here, “the Native Americans”, when the first settler set foot upon these shores, and the “slaves” in which were brought to these shores against their will and stripped of their country and heritage.

Nevertheless, there will always be those who will maintain their reasoning that it is by the skin color of one’s skin being the determining factor of one’s superiority or minority and in the eyes of one who see themselves as being a superior, a minority will never be accepted as being their superior.

President Obama speaks


I watched the video clip posted on the subject of President Obama's declaration to endorse publicly his views on the subject of Gay Marriages. I listened to his speech as well as watched his physical reaction to the speech and I am not quite sure that he believes in Gay Marriage. I think that the newly found sentiment is a ploy to win the votes of gay and lesbian voters. With this admission President Obama has opened a door that most politicians would never decide to open. I believe that his remark stunned the world. The way he made his speech I truly believe that although the President probably does not approve of gay and lesbian marriages, I do believe he is sympathetic to what they face day to day in society. I think that President Obama used his knowledge of the everyday struggles that same-sex couples endure that he wanted them to know that although he may not agree with their lifestyles he believes that they should be treated just as fair as other traditional couples. President Obama seemed to be very selective about his choice of words so that he would not offend anybody in the gay and lesbian community. President Obama chose to persuasively and adamantly give his support to the gay and lesbian community. Obama uses several persuasive annotation of the struggles concerning the lives of all military orientated personnel by appealing to the,” American Defense”, side of the issue in which homosexuals, as well as heterosexuals, gave their lives to protect and defend this nation. To his credit President Obama uses numerous words of persuasive imagination, but this speech will still cause a recoil because of his public opinion.  President Obama stated, “It is important for me to just go ahead and affirm, that I think same sex couples should get married”. This statement should be looked upon for what it is, just an opinion. I also think that President Obama's speech was very effective because it caused a stir that will bring considerable changes to his new campaign.

Robbing the poor

In her essay "When All Else Fails, Rob the Poor", Barbara Ehrenreich describes how society tends to take advantage of the financially unstable Americans. This article explains how with the way society and businesses make it un-achievable for the less fortunate to become a part of a higher income bracket. Ehrenreich explains how major credit card companies treat people from a lower income bracket. First these credit card companies charge the poor with higher interest rates. "Gary Rivlin, who wrote "Broke USA," calculated that the poor pay an effective surcharge of about $30 billion a year for the financial and banking services they use." She also explains how employers are legally allowed to keep a big portion of money which should be paid out to employees. Many companies fail to pay their employees minimum wage and also the required amount of money for overtime worked. Ehrenreich, also states Kim Bobo, concludes in her book "Wage Theft in America" how U.S. employers pocket around $100 billion a year through these practices. In this article, Ehrenreich explains how the government is the biggest transgressor of being prejudice and taking advantage of the poor. The state keeps creating incompatible punishments to minor infractions that are made. This article is effective in using logos such as "Payday Advance" making this an invitation to the poor having them believe that their using this system will help them get ahead, while in actuality their desperation is just another way for companies to take advantage of the poor and weak willed. Ehrenreich describes this process as a "legal loan shark".  Ehrenreich's articles expresses pathos, by sharing the story of the homeless Michigan woman. I believe that Ehrenreich's article allows its readers to know exactly what is going on in the society of the United States and it really makes your stomach turn when you think about what happens everyday in your own backyard. America used to be all about helping people, just because the people that need help are poor it doesn't make you any less of a person.

Friday, May 25, 2012

Christina vinson Discussion post 2

Christina Vinson May 27, 2012 "When All Else Fails, Rob The Poor" This article begins by stating before we can do something for the poor, there are some thing we need tostop doing to them. The first problems she identifie is, many lenders, cash, advance companies, and pawn shops rob the poor of the little or no monies they have. The purpose of this article is to bring awareness to the people who take advantage of the poor. If you want to get out of debt and stop the cycle of poverty,you must not allow anyone to rob you. This article brings attention to employees and creditors concerning making laws that would stop all from stealing from the poor. Barber Ehrenrich closes with this statement. No one should be incarcerated for debt or squeezzed for money they have no chace of getting their hands on. These are no bainers, and should take precedence over any long-term talk about generting jobsor stengthening the safety net

UC Problem: When Academics are Advocates

   The article begins with a thesis statement, " Political advocacy corrupts academic institutions." The problem that he identifies is that in California the Constitution states that: " The university shall be entirely independent of all political or secretarial influence and kept free therefrom." Despite the state Constitution the basis to the left is now accepted as a routine part of University of California education. He assumes his readers are Republicans by negative connotations directed toward liberal thinking. His purpose seems to bring awareness of the state of higher education in his country by using the University of California. The writer appeals mainly to logic by stating how Democrats outnumber Republicans in the faculty of University of California. He also states because of the mindset of the faculty members, students graduate college without knowing how to reason, write, or read complex material. He doesn't address any arguments against his thesis. Finally, he concludes by making the point that radical activism has replaced academic knowledge in campus classrooms. The politicized university is an intellectually bankrupt one. Overall, the argument that is presented in this article is ineffective because the writer is using facts from one university and making broad generalization I agree that political views should be kept out of the curriculum of academia, but I know the University of California is extremely liberal colleges. That being said, individuals with the same thinking will be attracted to University of California. College is a place for individual to expand their minds, learn to think, and find their passion.   

Discussion Post #2 week 2

Al Gore speaks passionately on the subject global warming. He is aware of our changing climates and increase in natural disasters. In his speech on global warming he stands in front of a crowd of highschoolers who were invited to hear him speak. He makes a relationship with them by comparing how he was once their age and faced challenges like we do today. Al Gore speaks to encourage action on the subject, and seems confident he will inspire his listeners to do so. His purpose is to change new ideas into a universal conscience. To accept that global warming is a crisis that cannot be ignored. His audience is not against him and is left wanting to take action. You can tell by the uproar and excitement of the crowd throughout his whole speech. In order to persuade his audience he uses the three methods of appeal. Logos is applied when he refers to Ghandi, and JFK. He applies the method of Ethos when he relates to the audience when he talks about when he was young. Gore also relies on logos to convince his listeners by giving examples of the negative effects of global warming. Al Gore also grabs your attention when he uses a simile. He compares what happened during the civil rights movement and the idea of global warming. He states “people don’t want to see that the pollution that causes global warming is wrong, just like people did not want to see that racial discrimination was wrong.” Lastly, he used an allusion as a rhetorical strategy. He did that by quoting an African proverb. Overall, Al Gore makes a very effective speech about global warming. He successfully defined his purpose and relayed his message clearly. He is an excellent speaker and makes a strong connection with his audience.
            President Obama "Same Sex Marriage"

This has been a long drawn out controversy issue same sex marriage should it be legal? Now that the Presidential Election is coming up quickly, I feel that this was a way for President Obama to get the Gay/Lesbian people to be a supporter for his possible reelection for President. Although, his speech was compelling, I personally did not feel that he is certain about this idea. However, all people should be treated as equal no matter what.  Since the Armed Forces are under "Don't ask, Don't Tell", then why should it matter about same sex marriage. When Obama gave this speech is chose his words very carefully, so that it would not offend anyone. If Obama really means that he is for same sex marriage, he needs to be more convincing in the speech he gave. Because of his "coming out" about his feeling on this topic, might seem like a desperate plea for voters. This again is only my opinion about President Obama's speech supporting same sex marriage. My feeling is whatever someone wants to do to make themselves happy and that choice should be theirs. We do live in a free country???

                     When all else fails, rob the poor

In Barbara Ehrenreich's, article"When all else fails, rob the poor", she relays the different ways that employers, major credit card companies, and government take advantage of the weak and poor. Ehrenreich's gives compelling information about the poor is in a cycle that is virtually impossible to get out of and to be treated as an equal in our society. In her article, Ehreneich, gives examples of different ways that the poor are robbed of their money and dignity. The major credit card companies charge the poor high interest rates; in addition, to the late fees and also including in the interest. Gary Rivlin, who wrote "Broke USA," calculated the poor pay surcharges around $30 billion a year for banking financial services that they use. The employers taking money from their employees; for example, failing to pay minimum wage and failing to pay for worked hours or overtime that has been worked. Ehrenreich, states Kim Bobo, documents in her book "Wage Theft in America" states how U.S. employers pocket around $100 billion a year through these practices. The government is the worst offender, and poster case of a homeless Michigan woman who was jailed in 2009 failing to pay $104 a month to cover the room and board charges for her 16-year-old son's incarceration. The woman had received a back paycheck, and her thought was to pay for her son's jail stay. But the government confiscated the check and applied to her stay. The states keep creating harsher punishments for different offenses that are really just minor infractions. Ehrenreich's article is persuasive using the logo "Payday Advance", making a invitation to the poor and take advantage of their desperate needs. This is basically the legal "loan shark".  Ehrenreich's articles articulate pathos, by sharing the story of the homeless Michigan woman. I do feel that Ehrenreich's informs the readers exactly what is really going on in this society and quite frankly I am disgusted. America is all about helping people, well,  are poor considered people?

Discussion Post week 2 #1

Rhetorical Analysis to "When all else fails,rob the poor"


Barbara Ehrenreich begins her argument with two hypothetical situations.  She compares two jobs with very opposite incomes and uses the situations to express what one would score if the people were robbed. Also in the first paragraph she uses a metaphor, calling the poor a “juicy target” to make a business off of stealing from them. The problem she identifies is that because you are classified as poor, you are basically trapped in a whirl pool that sucks everything out of you, and gives you a very small chance to ever make up for what is taken away. She assumes her readers are unaware of the issue, and has a neutral but informative tone. Her purpose is to address the issue, and convince the readers to take action. In order to accomplish the purpose, the writer appeals to Logos by using cause and effect, and giving insight about the cash advance businesses, credit card companies, and the harsh and unjust laws that are just made to make a buck in the system.  She also appeals to Ethos by including stories of people who have felt the arrows shot at the poor. The writer refutes her argument by concluding with possible solutions. Her outcome is not clear but the bottom line is that “Before we can "do something" for the poor, there are some things we need to stop doing to them. Overall the argument Ehrenreich makes is effective because the actual issue is addressed clearly, she uses strong strategies to back up her argument, and finally it leaves you feeling more educated about these “Shark-bite” strategies that businesses and our own government are using to make money that has no value because all they are making is just more debt.

Why Bambi Must Go

   The negative effects of white-tailed deer on migratory bird populations has gone unnoticed. In the article "Bambi Must Go" the author uses several rhetorical arguments to inform and persuade the reader to take action against the white-tailed deer. First, he informs us on the former plight of the white-tailed deer population and the laws that were put in place to protect our hoofed neighbors. Second, he gives us some facts on the population of the white-tailed deer. Thirdly, he used the emotions to describe how the birds can not nest on the ground because the white-tailed deer have eaten the vegetation in which the migratory birds nest.
   For me the strongest argument was the use of facts to inform us on how the white-tailed deer population has increased. I know that too much of anything is bad, so whether the over population of the white-tailed deer is affecting the population or not, something should be done about the amount of deer in certain areas.
   The conclusion of this article emphasizes the negative effects of over population of the white-tailed deer, and a call to action to protect the forest against the white-tailed deer. Over population of the white-tailed deer depletes the underbrush of the forest. Migratory birds nest in the underbrush of the forest; therefore, the white-tail deer are affecting the population of the migratory birds.

Tuesday, May 22, 2012

Rhetorical Fallacies

http://www.latimes.com/news/opinion/commentary/la-oe-ehrenreich-stealing-from-the-poor-20120517,0,7201749.story
"When all else fails, rob the poor"


  In Barbara Ehrenreich's article on the L.A. Times, she talks about what the government and businesses do to the poor. The fallacies start from the beginning of Barbara's article with some for example, "Mug a janitor and you'll be lucky to get bus fare to flee the crime scene." she is making a generalization that all janitors are poor, not all janitors are poor. She uses this as a way to get her opinion out that organizations tend to steal from the "poor" people to make a "quick buck". Ehrenreich's fallacy helps enrich her story and bring readers into what she believes to a huge cause in America. She is willing to get the reader to feel sorry for the poor and help support her cause so that she can accomplish her goal. The biggest falacy that Ehrenreich uses is the appeal to pity, which she wants you to feel bad for the "poor" people which will promote her argument furthermore. Though not the most notable method of persuasion it works with her argument because of her evidence she provides to support her claim. 

Week 2 Business

Congratulations on making it through Week 1!  As we make our way into Week 2, I have some reminders, some observations and some questions.

Reminders:

Make sure you are blogging two discussion posts (200-300 words) and four responses (100-150 words) per week.  This is a fairly easy way to rack up points.  I gave full points to all posts and comments this first week, but I will be marking down for length in the coming weeks.  Also, it is fine to make comments that go off topic (in fact, I encourage it as an important part of community building!), but only on-topic comments will be given credit in future weeks.

Also - and this is a real plea from me - please make sure you are using the labels option at the right side of the posting screen to label your posts.  It's much easier for me to guarantee I will not miss one of your discussion posts if you make sure to label each one with "DQ" so I can sort them at the end of the week.

Observations:

You guys are doing a great job so far!  You've gotten the hang of the blog and most of you have used the Angel dropbox to successfully post your papers.

I've been reading along on the blog, if mostly silently, and I have really enjoyed your conversations thus far!  Who knew I would have so many fellow comics nerds in this class?

Questions:

I'd like feedback, if you're so inclined, as to how you are adjusting to using the blog for class discussions thus far.  I am finding the conversations here more engaging than the ones I usually see on the Angel discussion boards, but I would like to hear your questions, comments or concerns.  I would particularly like to know if there is any part of the course blog or the assignment sheet/essay posting process that is still confusing you.

I'm looking forward to another great week!

Agenda - Week 2: Rhetorical Analysis and Logical Fallacies


Practical Argument Readings:

  • Chapter 4: “Writing a Rhetorical Analysis” (67-87)
  • Chapter 5: “Understanding Logic and Recognizing Fallacies” (89-126)
  • Chapter 7: “Planning, Drafting and Revising and Argumentative Essay” (189-216)

Presentations:

Check frequently for added links

Resources:


Discussion Questions:

  • Watch the political videos in my earlier post.  Choose one of those videos and analyze its rhetorical situation, appeals and rhetorical strategies.  Is the speech effective or ineffective?  Why?
  • Review one of the political videos in my earlier post for logical fallacies.  Which ones can you find?  How likely do you think the average viewer would be to notice them?  How do they effect your own perception of the effectiveness of the speech?
  • Choose one of the editorials listed in the Resources section above.  Using the "Template for Rhetorical Analysis" on page 85 of PA as a model, write a brief analysis of your selected reading.
  • Choose one of the editorials listed in the Resources section above.  Answer the "Identifying the Elements of Deductive Argument" questions on page 102 of PA of the "Identifying the Elements of Inductive Argument" questions on page 112 of PA.  Explain why you selected the set of questions you did.
  • Choose one of the editorials listed in the Resources section above and analyze it for rhetorical fallacies.  Identify the fallacies in the article and explain how and why the writer uses them and whether they undermine his/her overall argument.

Assignment:

Essay 2, due Monday, May 28th at 11:59 pm.  (I'm giving you an extra day due to the long weekend.)  The assignment sheet is posted to the Lessons page of Angel as Essay 2: Rhetorical Analysis.

Political Statements


President Obama on gay marriage:



Ron Paul and Rick Santorum on gay marriage:


Al Gore on climate change:


George Bush on climate change:


Monday, May 21, 2012

Catch-Up Day

Happy Monday, Everyone!

This first week, I know you are all busy getting used to what and where to post, so I am extending a catch-up day to let you all make sure you are on target before we move on to our work for Week 2.

As you will know from the syllabus, I do not accept late work.  Today will be the one exception to that rule.  If you have missing work from Week 1, I will let you catch up on it today.  Here is what you should have completed thus far:

  • Posted two discussion posts of 200-300 words each to the course blog.
  • Posted four responses of 100-150 words each to your classmates' discussion posts.
  • Posted your first essay to the Essay 1 dropbox on the Lessons page of Angel.  (This should not be emailed to me or posted to the course blog or tumblr.)
  • Posted the visual you discussed in Essay 1 to the course blog.  (The assignment sheet noted to post the visual to tumblr, but since no one has done so, and you're all used to posting here by now, this seems the easier solution.)
I have extended the deadline on all of these tasks to 11:59 pm tonight, so if you are behind, take this opportunity to catch up before I post this week's agenda.  If you are still have problems using the course blog or finding the resources on Angel, please contact me and I will be happy to meet you in person or by phone to walk you through everything.